The Best Baseball Betting Sites New York

BetRivers

Deposit match bonus of $250 with 250MATCH

4.4/5

Start Betting!

T&Cs apply. Must be 21+ and physically in the state

Disclaimer: Atnewyork is supported by its audience. When you click our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional costs to you.

Why Bet at Top New York Baseball Betting Sites

Betting online is convenient, safe, fair, and can be done anywhere in the state where you can access the internet. All of our top baseball betting sites NY have earned a local gaming license, which ensures that you have access to the best betting products. Whether you’re looking to live stream games or place simple line bets, you can do it here.

The Best NY Baseball Online Sports Betting Sites

To get this guide started, we’ve highlighted the top legal baseball betting sites in New York with the following mini-reviews. In each, we’ve covered important details such as their platforms, odds, live betting features, and welcome bonuses. For more information, you can read our individual reviews on this site.

BetMGM

The BetMGM sportsbook was one of the first sportsbooks to launch in New York, having its debut in January 2022. It is also the most popular online betting site in the USA for major leagues such as baseball. It is an official betting partner of MLB, ensuring that its odds are fair and accurate.

It is the platform of the MGM Resorts group and utilizes the same high-quality system as the company’s land-based sportsbooks. It has a powerful platform and is available to download on mobile devices. You’ll be able to take advantage of plenty of baseball markets for both pre-match and live wagers.

BetRivers

The BetRivers sportsbook is renowned for offering 17 different sports categories, including several leagues for baseball. This includes both the US MLB and Korea’s major baseball league. As a new player, you’ll be entitled to a hefty welcome bonus in the form of a large first-time bonus bet. 

Its desktop and mobile platforms have been beautifully designed for intuitive bet-building, and its bet slip is versatile for both pre-match and live wagers. There are several major payment methods accepted and the site provides a generous rewards program so that you can benefit from every dollar wagered. 

Caesars

The Caesars Sportsbook utilizes the world-class sports betting technology provided by William Hill, which is one of the oldest oddsmakers in the world. You’ll be able to wager on several baseball leagues here, though its official partnership with Major League Baseball ensures that these have the best odds.

Perhaps its primary highlight is its Live Betting lobby, which utilizes official league data to ensure bettors have the most up-to-date game information and statistics to inform their wagers. You can even live stream some sports. The sportsbook technology is of the highest quality and promises a stable betting experience.

FanDuel

For over a decade, FanDuel has been impressing US sports fans with its top daily fantasy sports platform. In recent years, it has grown to become one of the most popular online sportsbooks, especially for betting on Major League Baseball games. It too has partnered with the MLB to promise competitive odds.

New customers can claim a first-time bonus bet of up to $1,000 that can be wagered on baseball games. Of all of the platforms on this list, FanDuel’s website is perhaps the most attractive and user-friendly. This is especially evident in its attractive live betting platform.

DraftKings

DraftKings is another top sports betting platform that started as a DFS site and has since grown to dominate the New York betting market. The site is trusted by users and sports leagues alike for its promise of a top betting experience, and its collaboration with the MLB ensures great insights for picks and competitive odds.

You’ll be able to claim a welcome bonus as a new player and enjoy remote betting through its powerful mobile betting apps. There are a number of other sports leagues on offer to wager when the baseball season is on break, including the NFL, NBA, and NHL. 

About Welcome Bonuses

The best NY betting sites for baseball will provide players who have never held an account with the site to claim a welcome bonus. In some cases, you’ll need to provide a promo code when you sign up, while others will allow you to opt in with a click of a button and a qualifying deposit

These offers vary and can include a deposit match bonus, or a bonus bet. As a return user, you may also be able to claim boosted odds for baseball bets. Just be sure to read the terms and conditions for each NY baseball betting bonus before you claim as you’ll need to meet certain requirements to convert them into cash.

Top Local NY Baseball Teams and Players

As the birthplace of baseball, New York is home to some of the most iconic baseball teams and celebrated players of all time. Fortunately, you’ll be able to wager on these teams at all of our top sportsbooks. In this section, we’ve outlined some of the great current teams and players to back with your bets.

MLB Teams

New York is home to two Major League Baseball teams. These are the Bronx-based New York Yankees and the Queens-based New York Mets. With their iconic pin-striped uniforms, the Yankees are undoubtedly one of the most celebrated and successful sports teams in US Major League sports history.

The three most consistent Yankees players include Aaron Judge, Carlos Rodon, and Gerrit Cole, all of which can be backed with player props. The Mets have won only two World Series titles in their 60-year history but still have a fervent following. Top players include Pete Alonso and Jacob deGrom.

College Teams

There are over a dozen NCAA college baseball teams based in New York. However, you cannot bet on baseball games in New York that feature local college teams. This is to protect the integrity of leagues and the mental health of young players. However, you can wager on out-of-state college team games.

Mobile Baseball Betting Apps

All of our top sites have created native New York baseball betting apps so you can easily place your wagers at home or on the go. These are available to download on iOS and Android smartphones and tablets and support all major account functions, including bet building and live streaming.

You can create an account on your mobile, make payments, and even claim promos and rewards. These apps are secure and legitimate as long as you have downloaded them through the App Store or Google Play store. Just note that access will be blocked in states that have outlawed sports betting or haven’t licensed your chosen sportsbook.

The Betting Options

You are able to make an array of wagers for baseball, whether they be singles or parlay. The most common form of baseball bet is a moneyline, which is a simple wager on which team will win. You can also respond to sportsbook projections in totals or spreads.

Other bet types that are supported are player props, which are projections on how certain players will perform, and futures, which could be a wager on which team will win the World Series. These bets can be made in both pre-match and live betting forms.

Live Betting and Streaming

All of our top NY baseball betting sites have also provided live betting opportunities through distinct Live lobbies. This allows you to wager on games as they happen, and allow you to earn payouts before a game has finished. However, be mindful that these are faster-paced and require some prior research.

Sportsbooks will provide live bettors with statistics and game overviews to ensure that wagers can be informed. In most cases, you’ll also be able to live stream sports while you wager on them, though only DraftKings and FanDuel are the only ones that stream Major League Baseball games.

The Quality of the Odds

Through their partnerships with major leagues, our top sportsbooks can provide odds that are informed by accurate official league data. Their odds are also informed by their profit margins, which for popular sports such as baseball must be low in order to offer competitive prices. As licensed betting sites, all of our offers provide fair odds.

That said, their prices will fluctuate, so you’ll want to commit to your own odds comparisons before placing your bet. This can be more difficult with live betting as it is a faster pace and odds fluctuate rapidly. It is helpful to hold accounts with several betting sites to secure the best odds and payouts.

The Web Platform

The quality of a sportsbook’s web platform has a major impact on the satisfaction of users’ experiences betting. You’ll want to choose a site that has an aesthetic and design that suits your needs. They should be intuitive and user-friendly, and be stable to ensure they don’t crash while you’re building time-sensitive wagers.

Before you sign up for any site, you’ll be able to check out its betting lobby to gauge whether you like what you’ve found. We have recommended the platform’s on this page as they have a strong reputation for quality web design and security.

The Payment Methods

It’s important that you choose an online sportsbook that supports multiple payment options, especially those that you frequently use. All of our recommended sportsbooks accept numerous methods, including debit and credit cards, bank transfers, and eWallets. Some also accept mobile payments. The following are the available payment options for NY sports bettors.

• Visa and Mastercard
• American Express
• PayPal
• Play+
• Bank Transfers
• Paysafecard
• Trustly
• Venmo
• PayNearMe
• Apple Pay
• Google Pay
• eCheck
• VIP Preferred
• Cash at Casino Cage

Be mindful that not all of the above methods are available at every site. Each method also has varying transfer characteristics, with varying withdrawal times and minimum transfer requirements. We recommend using PayPal and Play+ where possible as these are the fastest and most convenient methods. 

Safety, Security, and Support

In order to be granted a license from the New York State Gaming Commission, betting sites must meet minimum safety and security requirements. To do this, you’ll find that your connections and transfers are protected with SSL encryption technology, which prevents hackers from stealing your data.

When you join, you must verify your age and identity through the KYC process. This stops minors and self-excluded players from joining and also prevents money laundering. Licensed sites must also offer responsible gambling tools such as self-exclusion and expert support to minimize the risk of problem gambling harms.

Another element that contributes to maintaining users’ well-being is customer support. Top providers will offer support in numerous contact methods that are available 24/7 such as telephone, email, and live chat. The most convenient method is live chat as it tends to yield the fastest and most helpful responses.

How to Sign Up

When you’ve chosen your ideal sportsbook, you’ll need to create an account to start betting. This is a fast and easy process. Click the Register button on the homepage, then provide your name, address, and contact details. Then, submit a copy of your ID to verify your age and identity.

Once this has been completed, you’ll be able to make your first deposit. You may be prompted to enter a promo code or opt into a bonus offer. If this is the case, check that your deposit meets the minimum requirements. Once your deposit has cleared, you’ll be free to start betting.

How to Bet on Baseball

With your account now created and funded, you’ll be ready to start betting. Head to the betting lobby to find all available sports. Click on baseball, then your preferred league. You’ll then see all available events to wager on. Click the event title to find the full list of markets.

Select the odds that interest you to add them to your bet slip, then set your stake below them. Alternatively, make multiple selections and click the parlay tab to calculate them together. The process is exactly the same for live betting, though these odds are found in a separate Live lobby.

NY Sports Betting Laws

These legal online baseball betting NY sites have all earned a license from the New York State Gaming Commission, which is the sole regulator for land-based and online gambling in the state. Sports betting has been available since 2022 after it was legalized in the 2021 state budget.

The current law is based on Senate Bill S17D and sees that up to nine sportsbooks can be granted a betting license in New York. The law states that players must be over 21 years old to legally sports bet, with betting revenues taxed at a rate of 51 percent.

Frequently Asked Questions

Now that we’ve come to the end of this legal baseball betting NY guide, we hope that you can confidently choose a sportsbook that suits your needs. If you are after quick answers to your queries about this subject, keep reading. Below, we’ve addressed common queries, such as the legality of mobile betting and how to bet.